The Ana Obregón case has triggered an actual earthquake that has reached the Congress of Deputies.
The Ana Obregón case has triggered an actual earthquake that has reached the Congress of Deputies. Surrogacy (these against this observe name it surrogate wombs) has totally entered the social and political debate, even though it's not a brand new path when it comes to attaining motherhood and fatherhood for some ( amongst them, additionally well-known and wealthy).
Neither is it a brand new problem in Congress, the place it has been mentioned extensively on quite a few events (most just lately, with the passage of abortion legislation reform, which features a ban on surrogacy companies ), with the only real assist of Ciutadans. Neither is it new within the judicial sphere, the place even the Supreme Court docket (the final time, in 2022) has expressed itself conclusively and with out leaving any doubt about what it thinks of the surrogacy contract : “It entails harm to the curiosity of the minor and an exploitation of the lady which can be unacceptable; each are handled as easy objects, not as folks endowed with the dignity of their situation as human beings”.
With the information that Ana Obregón has resorted to surrogacy to be a mom, the talk has been revived (tempered by her age, 68 years previous) though behind all of the fuss that has been generated, the truth is that regulation won't be confronted, at the very least not within the brief time period. As a result of no get together, besides Residents, has any intention of reopening the talk. Not even the PP, which within the midst of the noise of the information pretended to be open to debating "altruistic" surrogacy (with out fee to the expectant mom other than the bills this entails).
The controversy won't be addressed on this legislature, which is able to quickly finish, but additionally within the subsequent one, regardless of the end result, acknowledge the PSOE, Podem, PP and Vox MPs consulted by this newspaper. And it's that each one of them, who reject this observe, don't wish to open a debate that they have no idea the place it could possibly lead.
And this regardless of being conscious of the diploma of inconsistency concerned in contemplating this sort of being pregnant unlawful in Spain (the 2006 Legislation on Assisted Human Replica Methods), however on the similar time it's legalized by the registration of the creatures within the Civil Registry. The crime goes unpunished as a result of it's carried out in international locations the place it's authorized (courtroom or consular documentation is required to assist it) and, as soon as right here, the registration of youngsters can't be prevented following the rules of the European Court docket of Human Rights ( HDH). In reality, France has been condemned on a number of events for not permitting the filiation of those youngsters, arguing that refusing to acknowledge the organic filiation of youngsters with their dad and mom for having resorted to this system would go in opposition to the elemental proper respect for personal life enshrined within the European Conference on Human Rights.
Nearly all of Congress, at this second, hopes that the talk on surrogacy will as soon as once more be relegated to the oblivion of the general public for some time, though they acknowledge that it's going to not be straightforward. The pink press won't cease reporting on Ana Obregón.
Post a Comment