India’s government and its greens disagree on what counts as forest

AT THE COP26 local weather summit in Glasgow final 12 months, when greater than 100 international locations dedicated to ending and reversing deforestation by 2030, India, dwelling to a few of the world’s greatest and most biodiverse forests, demurred. Irrespective of: India’s forests appear to be thriving—at the very least on paper. Between 2019 and 2021 India gained 1,540 sq km in forest cowl, in accordance with a biennial report revealed final month by the Forest Survey of India (FSI), a authorities company. Over the previous 20 years, says the report, forest cowl has grown by 5.7%, or round 40,000 sq km, an space roughly the dimensions of Switzerland.

This must be excellent news. Forests are a boon for the atmosphere. Lots of India’s poorest folks depend upon them for his or her livelihoods. But India’s greens are unimpressed. They are saying the FSI’s definition of “forest” is deceptive and has been for the previous 20 years. Formally, any patch of land better than a hectare with cover cowl of at the very least 10% counts as a forest regardless of who owns it or to what use it's put. By the FSI’s reckoning, tea estates within the hills of east India, cashew plantations on the western coast and parks within the posh suburbs of Delhi, the capital, all qualify. The FSI “can’t be accused of favouring solely tree-clad areas in counting India’s forests”, M.D. Madhusudan, an ecologist, quipped on Twitter, illustrating his level with a scattering of bushes within the scorching desert of Rajasthan, a western state.

Certainly, virtually all the rise in India’s forest cowl previously two years has been pushed by development in plantations. Of the forest added since 2019, solely 31 sq km got here in “recorded forest areas”, that means precise forests. World Forest Watch, an internet tracker that makes use of a stricter definition, means that forest cowl may very well have fallen by 3.4% between 2002 and 2020.

The federal government says its definition aligns with worldwide norms. It additionally stresses that each tree, whether or not in a metropolis, plantation or jungle, offers some ecological profit. That is true. But high quality issues: totally fledged forests, with dense canopies, present habitats to animals and well being advantages to people.

The true downside could also be methodology moderately than definitions. The FSI report is compiled utilizing knowledge from satellite tv for pc pictures, which battle to see the forests for the bushes. Raj Bhagat, an professional on distant sensing, says that with out rigorous ground-level surveys to complement the information, the reported change in forest cowl is simply “noise”. Furthermore, the satellite tv for pc knowledge are usually not simply accessible, Mr Bhagat and others complain, thwarting makes an attempt at crowdsourced verification. Anoop Singh, the FSI’s director-general, insists the methodology is powerful, particularly given the constraints of time and assets. And the information can be found for anybody to buy—at a hefty value.

For extra protection of local weather change, register for The Local weather Situation, our fortnightly publication, or go to our climate-change hub